Understanding Real Estate Commissions in Colorado: How Buyer's Agent and Listing Agent Commissions Work
By Brandy Unruh, REALTOR® | Compass
Real estate commissions are one of the most frequently misunderstood parts of buying and selling a home. Many people wonder who pays the commission, how buyer's agents and listing agents are compensated, and whether commissions are negotiable. The reality is that every transaction is unique. This guide explains how commissions typically work in Colorado, the difference between buyer representation and seller representation, and why compensation structures can vary from one transaction to the next.
A real estate commission is compensation paid for professional services provided during a real estate transaction. These services often include marketing, negotiation, transaction management, market analysis, contract guidance, coordination with lenders and title companies, and helping clients navigate what is often one of the largest financial decisions of their lives.
While many people think of commission as a single fee, there are often multiple parties involved in a transaction. The exact compensation structure can vary depending on the brokerage agreements, the services provided, the type of property, and the local market.
One of the most important things to understand is that there is no universal commission structure. Real estate commissions are negotiable and can vary significantly from one transaction to another.
What Does a Listing Agent Do?
A listing agent represents the seller during the sale of a property. Their primary responsibility is to help position the home competitively in the marketplace and guide the seller through the selling process.
Typical listing agent responsibilities may include pricing strategy, professional marketing, photography, property preparation recommendations, showing coordination, offer negotiations, contract management, inspection negotiations, appraisal support, and closing coordination.
The level of service can vary dramatically from one agent to another. Some agents provide minimal services while others offer comprehensive marketing plans, extensive communication, strategic pricing analysis, and hands-on transaction management.
What Does a Buyer's Agent Do?
A buyer's agent represents the buyer's interests throughout the home-buying process. While many people focus primarily on showing homes, the reality is that showing properties is often only a small portion of the overall work involved.
A buyer's agent may help evaluate neighborhoods, identify potential concerns with properties, negotiate contract terms, coordinate inspections, navigate financing timelines, communicate with lenders and title companies, review disclosures, and help buyers make informed decisions.
The buyer's agent has a fiduciary responsibility to their client and serves as an advocate throughout the transaction.
Who Pays the Buyer's Agent in Colorado?
This is one of the most common questions consumers ask.
In Colorado, it has historically been common for the seller to offer compensation that may be used to compensate a buyer's agent. However, that does not mean the seller always pays the buyer's agent in every transaction.
There are situations where a buyer may be responsible for compensating their own agent. There are also situations where compensation is negotiated as part of the overall contract terms between the buyer and seller.
Every transaction is unique, and compensation should always be discussed and understood before entering into an agreement.
The important takeaway is that while seller-paid buyer agent compensation is common in Colorado, it should never be assumed. Buyers and sellers should understand how compensation is being handled in their specific transaction.
Are Real Estate Commissions Negotiable?
Yes.
Real estate commissions are negotiable and are determined by agreement between the parties involved.
There is no standard commission rate required by law, and compensation can vary based on property type, market conditions, service levels, complexity of the transaction, and other factors.
Because every property and situation is different, conversations about compensation should focus on services provided, expertise offered, and overall value rather than simply comparing percentages.
Understanding Value vs. Cost
One of the biggest misconceptions in real estate is that all agents provide the same service.
Just like hiring an attorney, contractor, financial advisor, or accountant, service levels can vary significantly between professionals.
Some consumers prioritize minimizing upfront costs. Others prioritize experience, negotiation skills, marketing expertise, communication, availability, and transaction management.
While compensation is certainly an important consideration, many consumers find that evaluating the overall value received is equally important.
As with many professional services, the least expensive option is not always the best fit for every situation, and the most expensive option is not automatically the best either. The goal is finding the right balance of expertise, service, and value for your specific needs.
How Market Conditions Impact Compensation
Real estate markets change constantly.
In highly competitive seller's markets, strategies may look very different than they do during balanced or buyer-friendly markets.
Inventory levels, buyer demand, interest rates, property condition, price point, and local market dynamics can all influence how transactions are structured.
This is one reason why broad assumptions about commissions can be misleading. What may be common in one market, neighborhood, or transaction may not apply in another.
Understanding the local market and working with knowledgeable professionals can help buyers and sellers make informed decisions that align with their goals.
Why Local Expertise Matters
Real estate is local.
What works in Erie may differ from what works in Broomfield, Lafayette, Louisville, Longmont, or other Northern Colorado communities.
Having a professional who understands local inventory trends, neighborhood dynamics, buyer behavior, contract practices, and market conditions can help clients navigate the process with greater confidence.
If you're considering buying or selling a home in Northern Colorado, understanding how commissions work is just one piece of a much larger conversation about strategy, representation, and achieving the best possible outcome.
For additional local real estate resources, visit BrandyUnruh.com or browse the real estate blog for more educational content.
Final Thoughts
Real estate commissions are often discussed but not always fully understood. While compensation structures can vary, understanding the distinction between buyer representation and seller representation is an important first step.
Every transaction is different. Every market is different. Every client has different goals.
The best approach is to ask questions, understand the services being provided, and make decisions based on value, expertise, and the outcomes you're trying to achieve.
Questions about real estate? Brandy answers every message herself, usually the same day.
“Brandy was fantastic to work with as we searched for a rental home in Colorado from out of state. She was extremely responsive, and did a great job listening to, and addressing our needs/requests in a home. She took video tours of homes for us and was careful to show all the details she could since we couldn't be there in person. Working with renters is often unpaid work for a realtor, but that did not stop Brandy from still giving her all to help us. I couldn't have found a better realtor to help us navigate an out of state move, and would highly recommend Brandy to anyone searching for a home in this area.”
E. E. · Google review
“Brandy is truly the best: attentive, incredibly knowledgeable about real estate/home value/home repair/etc, extremely responsive, proactive in her process of getting you ready, caring and warm, and hardworking. With my first home I didn't know what to expect. Buying my second home with Brandy's help made me feel so much less anxiety and so much more support. I couldn't recommend her more.”
Priya S. · Google review
“We had a phenomenal experience using Brandy as our real estate agent. She possesses deep, expert knowledge of the Erie market and is a true pleasure to work with. Her client onboarding is exceptional: during our initial "market education day," she asked such precise questions that the very first home she showed us turned out to be our perfect match. Brandy is efficient, highly intuitive, and fun to be around. We cannot recommend her highly enough!”
Jill S. · Google review
“Brandy and I recently wrapped up a transaction together, and it was a great experience all around. Her professionalism and communication were excellent from start to finish, and she made the process seamless for everyone involved: responsive, collaborative, and client focused. The kind of agent you hope to work with!”
Ryan F. · Google review
“I highly recommend Brandy for anyone looking to buy or sell! She's incredibly kind and compassionate, and her professionalism really shines through! She's knowledgeable about the local market and truly cares about her clients. Give her a call.”
Dan W. · Google review
“I've had the pleasure of knowing Brandy for several years, both personally and professionally, and can confidently say she is exceptional to work with. Her dedication to her clients, combined with her outstanding communication and professionalism, truly sets her apart. She consistently goes above and beyond, exceeding the standard of service I've experienced with many agents.”
Brianna F. · Google review
“Beyond Amazing!!! I have known Brandy about 8 years, we met on a kindergarten playground. From the day I met her there was something about her that hooked me. I knew if I asked her a question she would give me a detailed answer that would give me all of the info I needed. She is thorough, prompt, knowledgeable and definitely AMAZING! We just closed on a home, it was easy because of Brandy! We had no plans of purchasing a home but we did it!! I would definitely recommend Brandy to anyone, and have!! She will be there for you no matter what, a buyers market, a sellers market, both or neither! Trust me, she is the agent you need!”
Katy W. · Google review
“I've hired multiple realtors during my lifetime. Without a doubt, Brandy Unruh is far above and beyond all the others! What impressed me most, is her responsiveness, hard work, knowledge, honesty, and always having my back. She works tirelessly for her clients and her communication skills are exceptional, which are definitely important for real estate negotiations.”
C. C. · Google review
“Brandy is incredible to work with in every way! She will be sure to take the time to understand what's most important to you in your home buying or selling journey and ensure that your priorities remain top of mind! You will never feel like you're not being heard! She is exceptionally articulate and excellent when it comes to communication! You will always feel kept apprised! Consider yourself lucky to come across such a knowledgeable realtor and hire her the moment you get pointed in her direction! You will not be disappointed, and you will likely gain a lifelong trusted friend in the process.”
Brittany M. · Google review
“Brandy! Excellent is a good word to describe her incredible work ethic, personality and love of her job. Brandy helped me find the perfect house for my situation, needs and desires. Our particular sale was long distance and Brandy was always attentive, responsive, and calm in explaining the specifics in an often complicated transaction. I need to stress calm because I tend to get overly anxious about things but, thanks to Brandy, everything was handled perfectly in a professional and easy manner. I highly recommend Brandy for your real estate needs as I'm certain she will perform the job from start to finish without a hitch and with a smile on her face.”
Audrey M. · Google review
“Brandy Unruh is the best realtor in Erie, CO (in my opinion). She bought us a house, and sold our old house, with superb skills and professionalism. We never had it so good.”
Craig E. · Google review
“I've had the pleasure of working with Brandy on several projects over the years, and she's the real deal. Her energy is contagious. Always optimistic, driven, and fully committed to whatever she takes on. She brings a creative edge to her work that really sets her apart, and her attention to detail shows in everything she does. If you're looking for a realtor who works hard, communicates clearly, and truly cares about her clients, I can't recommend her enough.”
Brianna H. · Google review
“Brandy is exceptionally bright and professional. She has the passion for service and a zest for knowledge that runs deep. She combines her super powers to bring results for her clients. She has a confidence to lead, that's well deserved. Brandy is an amazing resource, guide and expert in Real Estate. She is nurturing and caring to create a wonderful experience through what can be a challenging move. I feel confident to refer buyers and sellers to Brandy for quality results and a joyful experience.”
Stacey R. · Google review
“I've seen firsthand the passion, integrity, and dedication that Brandy brings to her work. She consistently goes above and beyond for clients, making the buying or selling process smooth and stress-free. If you're looking for someone who is knowledgeable, trustworthy, and genuinely cares about helping you find the right home, she's who you should call!”
Lauren G. · Google review
“Brandy is so knowledgeable about real estate. She's a spectacular human who will go to great lengths to help her clients!”
Kristin F. · Google review
“Brandy is so professional and easy to work with. Whether you are buying or selling, she's the one!”
Andrea M. · Google review
“Brandy went above and beyond in helping me through the home buying process as a single mom. She also encouraged me every step of the way, often reminding me, "You can do hard things!" I recommend her without reservation.”
Della R. · Google review
“As a fellow Realtor, I absolutely love when I get the chance to work with Brandy! She is a true professional who really cares about her clients, and has a great reputation in the industry. I can't recommend her enough! Brandy is top-notch and navigates the ever-changing market with ease and knowledge.”
April P. · Google review
“Brandy is incredible to work with! She is attentive, kind, knowledgeable and provides outstanding service. I am a painter and have worked with many of her clients and they all rave about her!!! Highly recommend!”
Erin H. · Google review
“Brandy is a fantastic realtor and a true professional. Super knowledgeable about the area and goes the extra mile for her clients. If you're looking to buy or sell, Brandy is a tremendous resource to have in your corner and on your team.”
Skylar W. · Google review
“Brandy is a true professional at what she does. She brings her warm personality and takes care of business for her clients. She educates them on home buying and assists to make their home owning dreams come true. I will always be happy to refer her to anyone looking to buy or sell a property.”
Adina S. · Google review
“Brandy is fantastic! She's known for being professional, kind, and incredibly client-focused. I have done business with agents all across the front range, and there are a few that stand out. Brandy is definitely one of them and she absolutely shines. Those that are kind, collaborative, and knowledgeable are the ones that I know are giving their clients the service they deserve. If you're looking for an agent who will truly be there for you every step of the way, Brandy is an easy choice. Highly recommend!”
M. S. · Google review
“I've had the privilege of knowing Brandy for over six years and have had the pleasure of working closely with her on the real estate side for the past two. She is truly one of the most genuine, hardworking, and knowledgeable agents I know. Brandy works relentlessly for her clients, always going the extra mile to make sure they feel supported, informed, and confident throughout the entire process. Beyond her professionalism, she is simply an amazing human being: kind, trustworthy, and a true joy to work with. I cannot recommend her highly enough to anyone looking to buy or sell a home!”
Brandy P. · Google review
“Brandy Unruh excels at connecting with people and caring for them genuinely. Your success means the world to her and she'll go more than the extra mile to ensure that. If you are looking for a partnership with someone who is invested in the very best, Brandy is the best choice you could make for yourself.”
Janette E. · Google review
“Brandy is exceptionally knowledgeable about all aspects of real estate and consistently goes above and beyond for her clients. More than that, she is one of the most genuine and kind people you'll ever meet. Buying or selling a home can be a stressful experience, and having an agent like Brandy, who brings years of experience, manages deadlines and negotiations with precision, and remains calm and patient throughout the entire process, makes all the difference. Brandy is a truly solid choice to have by your side in your next real estate transaction.”
Shannon D. · Google review
“Brandy is the perfect person to walk you through a home purchase or sale. She's sweet, smart and willing to go the extra mile for her clients. I'd highly recommend her!!”
Megan C. · Google review
“Brandy is an absolute rockstar, and goes well above and beyond for her clients. Excellent communication from beginning to end, detail oriented, and she even showed up on a holiday to help us paint a deck! We could not have asked for a better real estate agent to help us find the home of our dreams!”
Samantha H. · Google review
“Brandy is a true professional. She knows her business. I could tell from the moment I met her that she would do the job right. And she did. We closed in less than a month even though I threw many curves at her. Thank you, Brandy!”
P. M. · Google review
“Thanks for all you do Brandy!”
Jenny J. · Google review
“I had the most beautiful experience with Brandy as my realtor! She was always helpful and supportive, and no matter what obstacles we encountered, she always had a solution or some honest advice that I appreciated. What I loved most about her was how friendly and down-to-earth she was. It made me feel so comfortable to work with her and trust her decision-making. She's amazing!”
Mecca S. · Google review
“Brandy is a top notch realtor in the north Denver area and she sets herself aside from others by being extremely thorough, knowledgeable, and the part I love most is she really listens to her clients needs and puts emphasis on each individual throughout her process. I highly recommend working with Brandy Unruh.”
Jeffrey B. · Google review
“She goes above and beyond for her clients, works diligently and communicates flawlessly during the purchase process, and will fight for you if any issues arise. She is a stellar real estate agent and friend, and I am so grateful we had her in our court while purchasing our first home!”
Katie E. · Google review
“Brandy is an outstanding realtor who made the impossible possible. I never thought I'd be able to find a home in my desired location and in my price range, but Brandy made this happen, and in only a few months. Thanks so much Brandy for making my dream come true!”
Lindsay S. · Google review
“Quite honestly I don't know how she does it. Brandy is, by far, one of the most amazing real estate agents and I have graciously had the pleasure of getting to work with twice. She explains what's going on throughout the process and creates a safe space to ask questions. Brandy is honest and kind with a side of hustle that makes her unique for whatever your future home dreams consist of. She's supportive and just as excited as you are about finding you the house you call home.”
Camille W. · Google review
“Brandy Unruh is a great realtor, professional, knowledgeable and a wonderful person. We have just been through a great experience with her as our realtor and sold our house at the right time, for the best price and in a very short time frame. She guided us through all of the process and did a wonderful job. I highly recommend her as a very competent realtor!”
Vera O. · Google review
“Brandy is a true real estate professional and a genuinely good person! She has an excellent eye for detail and works tirelessly to help her clients make their homes shine. Brandy cares about her town and is a great asset to the Erie community.”
BT B. · Google review
“Brandy is the best of the best! She made the process of buying a home in Colorado a breeze despite this crazy market. She has mastered the dying art of customer service and it is obvious that she genuinely cares about her clients on a personal level. Give Brandy a call! I can guarantee you won't be disappointed.”
Jordann K. · Google review
“I had a great experience buying...AND selling a home with Brandy! I even referred her to my daughter who ended up buying a home with Brandy! Not only a knowledgeable professional, a sweet and caring person!”
Lisa W. · Google review
“Brandy made finding and purchasing our home as easy as can be expected. Her knowledge of the local market is spot on. Furthermore, her reliability, hard work, and professional demeanor proved invaluable. Best of all, she has been a great resource for all home-related questions, even after the sale.”
